← All characters

Atheist

The Storyteller can break the game rules, and if executed, good wins, even if you are dead. [No evil characters]

Let us disperse with unnecessary conjecture and silly paranoia. There is a perfectly rational explanation for everything. Yes, a teacup may indeed be orbiting the planet, too small to see, but I shall drink my tea from the very real china in my very real hands.

Jinxes

Riot

During a riot, if the Storyteller is nominated, players vote. If they are "about to die", the game ends. If not, they nominate again.

How to run it (Storyteller)

Atheist removes all evil characters from the setup entirely, so the Storyteller is the sole adversary — you are permitted to break any game rule to make good's path to victory difficult and interesting (e.g. feeding false information, creating contradictions, letting players die unexpectedly). The nastiest ruling: if the Storyteller is executed during a Riot-triggered nomination chain, players must vote on that nomination normally; if the Storyteller would die, the game ends immediately and good wins. Watch for the moment players reach consensus on who to execute — if they execute you (the Storyteller) without enough information to justify it, good still wins, so calibrate your rule-breaking to make them earn that execution without it feeling arbitrary.

How to play

  • Reveal immediately or very early: the entire town must align on the Atheist game before anything else matters, because an Atheist world requires executing the Storyteller rather than a player, and that consensus takes time to build.
  • Audit the information: the Storyteller is allowed to lie to everyone, so map out contradictions in night information — if two players have mechanically incompatible claims that the Storyteller could not have generated honestly, that is evidence the Atheist game is real.
  • Build a coalition before nominating the Storyteller: you need the votes to execute them, and skeptical players will need to be convinced; identify the players getting the most suspicious or internally consistent information and use them as anchors for your case.
  • Do not wait until good is on the back foot: once too many players are dead and the town is in panic, they will default to executing each other, so push the Storyteller nomination while the group is still large enough to deliberate calmly.
  • Most common mistake: treating the Atheist game like a normal game where you protect yourself — your death is irrelevant since good wins on Storyteller execution even after you die, so spend your survival currency freely to gather allies rather than hiding your role.

How to bluff as the Atheist

  • Atheist is an extremely high-risk bluff because it reframes the entire win condition for good — only attempt it if you can sustain the narrative long enough to waste the town's execution economy on the Storyteller or on internal confusion.
  • Claim Atheist on day one with confidence and immediately push for the group to audit information contradictions; as evil, you have advance knowledge of what is true, so you can selectively highlight contradictions that implicate good players while steering attention away from your teammates.
  • The believable fake you provide is a 'contradiction audit' — point to two pieces of night information that look inconsistent and frame them as Storyteller mischief, even if you manufactured or know the real explanation; this makes the bluff feel substantiated.
  • The tell that exposes a fake Atheist: a real Atheist has no teammates to protect, so if you seem reluctant to nominate the Storyteller once the town is convinced, or if you steer votes toward players rather than the Storyteller at a critical moment, observant players will notice the incentive mismatch.
  • If playing a Demon who has gained the Atheist ability, you can legitimately claim Atheist since the Storyteller retains the option to break rules — but setup was not enforced, meaning evil players exist; use this to sow maximum confusion about whether the game is a real Atheist world.

Key interactions

Riot

During a Riot-driven nomination chain, if the Storyteller is nominated and the vote would kill them, the game ends instantly and good wins — players must understand this timing so they don't squander the Storyteller nomination during a Riot by failing to get the votes over the threshold.

Demon (with Atheist ability)

If a Demon acquires the Atheist ability, the Storyteller may still break rules and good can still win via Storyteller execution, but evil players are present in the game since Atheist's setup clause was never applied — this creates a hybrid game state that invalidates most normal Atheist deduction.